Home

Register

Tour SciLinks

Submit your Site

FAQ

  
Evaluation Criteria

How are web pages evaluated for SciLinks?

Here you can review the process that SciLinks use rubrics to evaluation Internet URL resources. The process of evaluating Internet resources required rigorous training to ensure that all SciLink teachers have a common understanding of the rubric's meaning and exhibited reliability in the rubrics' application.

Use the links to the right to take a closer look at each individual rubric:

Icon Filters

Icon Filters allow teachers to selectively view SciLink resources sorted by specific types of information such as hands-on investigation, lesson ideas, misconceptions, history of science, etc. In order for this to be a useful feature for teachers, all SciLinks were trained to be consistent in the selection of icons.

In addition, when evaluating an Internet resource for a specific icon (inquiry for example) we had to answer the question, should the URL resource be evaluated as potentially supporting a facet of inquiry if augmented in some way by the classroom teacher? Or does the activity support a complete inquiry or investigation without augmentation by the end-user. As with the entire rubric alignment process, it was decided that the information needed to be explicitly provided on the web page for it to be labeled or identified with an icon.

return to top

   

Rubrics

  • Authority: Information presented is reliable, valid, and authoritative
  • Design (overall): In addition to being educational, the materials are visually appealing and/or entertaining.
  • Interactivity: Interactive features, such as dynamic feedback based on user manipulation, is provided and add value to the site. Content provides the manipulation of data sets and simulations
  • Communication/Collaboration: Content allows communication/data exchange between content providers and students, as well as between distributed students via the Internet.
  • Scientific Inquiry: To what extent does the content, presentation method, and learner activity facilitate inquiry-based learning -- supported with real world examples
  • How Scientist Work/Nature of Scientific Inquiry: How students learn about what scientists do in the process of inquiry
  • Quality of Writing: Instructional and explanatory text is well written.
  • Resource Integration: The Web page is easily implemented, adds value to pre-existing resources, and is articulated to the Standards.

Copyright © 1999-2003 National Science Teachers Association